« REVIEW: Motorola ROKR E1 iTunes Mobile Phone | Home | Exclusive: Apple Plasma Displays to Rock MWSF (Updated) »
January 6, 2006
REVIEW: Garmin StreetPilot 2720 Portable GPS (Updated)
As an unabashed gadget geek, there's one toy that I've managed to resist for years: GPS. You see, I have this weird thing about commuting - I don't like it. No, let me make that clearer, I detest it. Sitting in traffic or spending a lot of time driving across creation is one of my least favorite things to do. So much so that I'd rather move closer to the office than commute.
Because of my short commutes (usually between 10 and 20 minutes) I've never really had the need for a GPS system. I know where I'm going because I drive the same route every day. But reading Rob Parker's review of the Quest 2 from Garmin on 14 November got me thinking that maybe there's something to this whole GPS thing after all.
GPS works by tracking your location by using several government satellites. According to Wikipedia:
The GPS system was designed by and is controlled by the United States Department of Defense and can be used by anyone, free of charge. The GPS system is divided into three segments: space, control and user. The space segment comprises the GPS satellite constellation of at least 24 satellites in an intermediate circular orbit (ICO) . The control segment comprises ground stations around the world that are responsible for monitoring the flight paths of the GPS satellites, synchronizing the satellites' onboard atomic clocks, and uploading data for transmission by the satellites. The user segment consists of GPS receivers used for both military and civilian applications. A GPS receiver decodes time signal transmissions from multiple satellites and calculates its position by trilateration.
I got my hands on the Garmin StreetPilot 2720 (US$1076.91) and have to admit that I don't know how I went this long without one. The StreetPilot 2720 is a portable GPS receiver that sits on top of your car's dashboard and tells you where you are at any given moment via a bright 3.8-inch WQVGA color, automotive-grade, sunlight-readable TFT display. It will give you precise turn-by-turn driving directions to any address, intersection, city or point of interest that you enter into it. The beanbag mount is great because you can easily move the GPS from car to car. The 2720 also ships with a dashboard mount that car be firmly attached.
Destinations and Points of Interest (POIs) are entered via the touch-screen and/or alphanumeric remote control, to get directions you click the "Go To" button. If you don't want to take your eyes off the road to read the on-screen directions the 2720 will speak them to you, a nice feature. There's even different voices and accents to suit your taste. You have the choice of using the on-screen map in either a three-dimensional perspective or top-down (track-up or north-up) view.

The StreetPilot 2720 comes pre-loaded with City Navigator North America NT maps containing detailed road maps throughout the entire United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico. This map database features nearly six million POIs —including hotels, restaurants, gas stations, ATMs, and attractions. If that's not enough, you can upload custom POIs such as restaurants and safety cameras but this must be done from a Windows-PC because Garmin doesn't offer Mac support.

The 2720 is phenomenal because it saves me time and effort every time I turn it on. I just moved to a new house in a new town and GPS systems are great for learning your surroundings. With just the interactive map turned on (no navigation) I learned the names of all the side roads, towns and geography that I wouldn't otherwise notice. Who reads street signs, anyway? With a GPS map up, you can't help but notice that you're passing a certain street, town or body of water. And since every detail is overlaid with its name, you can't help but to learn your surroundings over time.

Oh, and it's excellent for navigation too. Over the New Year's weekend I took a trip up to Connecticut to visit family and rather than get directions, proof them with Google Maps then sanity check those with a real map, I did nothing. I simply put the address into the GPS and departed. This alone probably saved me an hour of pre-mapping. When my host informed me that it was better to come up the Garden State Parkway and come across 287 (as opposed to coming through New York as the GPS was suggesting) I just did it. As soon as you miss your exit the GPS politely says "recalculating" and tells you the next best way to go.

The other killer feature on the 2720 is multiple destination travel or tours. I recently went to see several people in Delaware and, again, instead of pre-plotting several locations and the maps between each, I just brought a list of addresses and keyed them into the GPS. It was great! When I had to flip-flop my #3 and #4 appointments - no problem. I just put the new address into the GPS. This would have been a complete mess had I been relying on pre-printed online maps.

Now it's not prefect. There were a couple of times in the woods of Connecticut where I was off grid for a few minutes and the GPS had a tough time finding an address, but it was a tiny street in a very rural part of town. I imagine that this could be remedied by uploading a specific map - but I haven't tried this.
A must-have addition to the 2720 is Garmin's GTM 10 (US$214.27) FM-band traffic receiver that connects with a car radio/antenna system to provide real-time Traffic Message Channel (TMC) data to the StreetPilot 2720. The GTM 10 identifies problem areas on their moving-map displays. The GTM 10 is a small external adapter about the size of a large box of wooden matches that connects to the 2720 and notifies you of accidents, road construction, police, or emergency activities.

The Traffic Message Channel is a specific part of the Radio Data System that broadcasts real-time traffic update information via FM frequencies. The best part is that using the GTM 10 with the Garmin StreetPilot 2720 GPS provides dynamic routing options that changes with the incoming traffic information. When the TMC information is received by the 2720 and the unit is currently routing, it will display alternate options for the current route in order to lessen the effect of the traffic situation ahead. The GTM 10 module comes with a free 15-month subscription to Clear Channel Traffic. After that subscriptions can be purchased for US$60 per year.
I am awarding the Garmin StreetPilot 2720 portable GPS receiver an O'Grady PowerPick award for 2006 because it's incredibly useful, portable and has got me out of trouble more than a few times in the short time that I've been using it. It's only shortcoming is the lack of Mac support, but I haven't had to upload any maps to it, so it hasn't been an issue. If you haven't been introduced to the wonderful world of GPS, do yourself a favor and try one today.
Garmin StreetPilot 2720 - US$1076.91
Garmin part number: 010-00408-02
Garmin GTM 10 - US$214.27
Garmin part number: 010-00396-10
Posted by jasonogrady at January 6, 2006 11:26 AM
Category: Consumer Electronics
Digg This |
Post to del.icio.us |
Post to Furl
- Apple Offers Complimentary Repairs for Select MacBook Pro Notebooks with Nvidia Chips
- Apple Patent Suggests Possible Voice Commands for iPhone, iPod Touch and/or Apple TV
- Delicious Library Updated to 2.0.4
- Apple Releases Security Update 2008-007
- Adium X Reaches 1.3.2
- Apple to Hold Notebook Event on October 14th
- AT&T Launches Online Account Setup For iPhone 3G Customers
- Apple Announces iPhone Tech Talk World Tour
- Potential Next-Gen MacBook Shots Leaked, Lower Price Point Mentioned
- Opinion: Trying to Do the Right Thing
- Upcoming RealVNC Version to Add iPhone, Additional Handset Support
- Opera 9.60 Out the Door
- Shaker Pulled From App Store
- Blackberry Storm Enters Touch-Screen Device Fray (Updated)
- VLC Updated to 0.9.4
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.powerpage.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/8522
Comments
Yeah. Would love to have one but there is no freakin way I will part with 1K for one. Paper maps will work fine until they reach the sub $400 range. At that point I hope the auto makers have adopted a technology as good as this and install them in every auto sold.
Posted by: Charlie at January 6, 2006 12:06 PM
I bought a Garmin i3 over the summer and have used it in Ontario, New York and Florida and it makes driving so incredibly easy. While it does not have as many of the features of the larger units, the i3 is about the size of a baseball cut in half and easily fits into a carryon bag.
While in Florida, I entered all the popular locations into the memory. When my daughter, who had never driven in the Sunshine State went down for a visit, I felt confident enough of her being able to get around with the Garmin that I didn't worry. She got her Hertz Prius, popped the i3 on the windshield with it's suction cup and called up the condo's location from the memory. No problems, and she even found malls that I didn't know existed!
If you travel at all, the $350 US price is well worth it. When I showed it to a friend in Florida, he bought his and hers versions!
Perfect shoice for a pick, Jason!
Posted by: Stan Greenspan at January 6, 2006 1:23 PM
As a SatNav retailer and Mac junkie, it was great to read your review - well done on a very fair job.
Wish all the GPS/SatNav manufacturers would wake up to the need to offer Mac support for their software. Effectively they just come up as USB drives when connected, so it really shouldn't be difficult to port a version of the software to the OSX platform.
Also, take a look at the Garmin 7500 - what a cool system for RVs - 7" screen and all...
Posted by: Stuart McIntyre at January 6, 2006 1:27 PM
Are there any Mac-compatible GPS systems available on the market?
Posted by: Walt Atwood at January 6, 2006 4:42 PM
Look into the Garmin iQue 3600. I've had one for over two years. Its a full up Palm PDA with Garmin's GPS, mapping and nav, and integrates the palm address book, calendar, and nav. Mostly PC but Missing Sync has made a Mac I/F. Still need VPC or somebody's PC to build maps. I have a 2 GB SD card with every road, address, and business phone (all catagoized for easy searching) in North America.
Garmin also makes PocketPC versions.
Users group at http://forum.bargainpda.com/forumdisplay.php?f=53
Or
http://www.pdastreet.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?s=&forumid=108
With a lot of mac users, especially on the first forum.
I live in LA, and have discaded my Thomas Guide. A quick seach with an address and "Betty" takes me to any destination I need. A really marveloous program written buy one of the forum users called "FastFinger" makes a touch pad ou of he palm screen with scriptable activiies. I made a button to find the nearest Starbucks where ever I am - including an unexpected trip to Houston - as well as a few hundred ohers favorie actions. You'll find my scrips on either forum in the "FastFinger" sticky.
Because of the PDa integration it's one of my key toys.
It also does voice record and plays MP3's but I have both video and micro iPods so don't use that.
Posted by: Robert Pelzmann at January 7, 2006 12:58 AM
The Tom Tom Go 300 and 700 are Mac compatible.
Posted by: Alan Disler at January 7, 2006 2:18 AM
TomTom makes a Mac compatible GPS. I purchased one for under $500 after rebate. Works great, I never get lost...
Posted by: BJSilver at January 7, 2006 12:15 PM
Garmin doesn't just not support Macs. Garmin and is, and has been, antagonistic towards Mac owners and is even proud about the fact they don't support Macs. This has been a matter for discussion for many years on Mac-GPS discussion groups and it has never improved. Someone high in Garmin REALLY hates Macs.
Posted by: Art Busbey at January 7, 2006 10:11 PM
As others have noted, you can get a decent GPS system for less than $400.00. Also, I've never understood why anyone would pay $1,000 to $2,000 for the built-in versions for their car. Unless someone does a lot road trips starting from home, most people rent cars when they are away from home. That's when you need a GPS system the most. Portable versions are less expensive and can travel with you.
Posted by: Matt at January 8, 2006 9:17 AM
Hi there!
I used to have a Magellan 750 GPS, which had many features I liked, but had to return it because if you unplugged it for a few hours, it would sometimes take 30 min up to almost a day to lock back onto the GPS signal. this was an known issue with that particular brand. My question is, does the Gramin have similar problems or does it find the sats right away?
also, is does it run on batteries or just the cig lighter?
thanks!
Sven
Posted by: Sven at January 9, 2006 2:11 AM
A very nice article on the 2720. We've had a 2610 for nearly two years now. Same form factor, but only 2D maps, no custom POIs and no TMC. Still love it though. Here's my single warning - you will find your maps go out of date. That's when you're going to need a PC to install the new ones.
Posted by: WalterF at January 9, 2006 11:57 AM
i am looking for new maps for garmin street pilot2720 - i have factory loaded ver 7 but they are a bit old for area where I am- all help appreciated
ken@holliday.com
Posted by: falconken at April 3, 2006 5:33 PM

